Social media costs money.
We get it.
By now we've all come to realize that social media isn't "free". There are many costs, such as staffing and advertising (which this insightful infographic demonstrates) that marketers and business owners need to consider.
What I LIKE MOST about the infographic is that it goes on to list all the BENEFITS of an investment in social media, most of which are immeasurable. They (Social Media Today) list these benefits (which were gathered via an eMarketer survey) as a way of illustrating that marketers have dismissed "low cost" as a real benefit. A valid point to make, and an important one for their purposes. But to me, the most important point of this whole infographic is the fact that there are MANY benefits of social media, most of which are immeasurable, and all with considerable impact on the success of a business. Sure, we may not be able to calculate a numeric ROI (since we can't measure the total return), but the length of this list of benefits makes it hard to justify NOT investing in social media.
IMHO, there are a few missing from the list! Notably:
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
The case for investment in social media is compelling (perhaps overwhelming). The real question is whether or not you're taking advantage of all the benefits.
Any benefits that I missed? Don't forget to also check the ones in the infographic.
Too many businesses forget that social media is.... wait for it.... SOCIAL!
Social media is (supposed to be) a collection of real conversations between real people. They just happen to take place on a screen, rather than in person. Too often, though, businesses use social media as a channel to talk about their business, their offers, their events and so on. They treat social media as another channel for promotion. In other words, they talk about themselves.
With that in mind, look back at your posts, read them in succession, and imagine that you're saying all these things, in person, to real people. How do you sound? Do you sound like that annoying guy who only talks about himself? Are you saying anything that would be interesting to real people? My guess is (based on what I see every day on social media), NO.
You need to dedicate a considerable portion of your social feeds to interesting dialogue about things that have nothing to do with your business, just like you would in a real social setting! Real life conversations include all kinds of dialogue about current events, pop culture, and...wait for it... interesting topics! Eventually, the conversation may turn professional, but if you compare your social media feeds to what you talk about in real life to real people, there are surely vast differences in tone. And there shouldn't be.
The best example of real social engagement on social media is Mashable. They talk about all kinds of interesting things that have nothing to do with them. In the illustration above, I captured three recent posts: one about a nasty sea slug, one about the Paris attacks, and one about the Biebs. None of those posts are about about Mashable, a digital media website which describes itself as a "source for news, information and resources for the Connected Generation". They started in 2005 as a site focussed on technology and new media, but they quickly realized that when it came to their social media activity, they needed to be... wait for it...you know what's coming...SOCIAL! They talk a LOT about things that are interesting, regardless of how closely they relate to their business or their offerings. Slugs have nothing to do with tech. The Paris attacks have nothing to do with the Connected Generation. They talk about these things because they are interesting, and people listen. A LOT of people (they currently have more than 6 million Twitter followers).
THE LESSON FOR MARKETERS
You want to be interesting on social media, not self-promoting. Why? Because people listen to interesting brands. And the more interesting you are, the more likely you are to be remembered when those people need to buy a product that you just happen to sell. Social media's not for inspiring a purchase. It's for engaging in dialogue that makes you memorable. It's that brand awareness that will lead, one day, to purchase consideration.
How will you know if you're doing it right? Go back to your social media feeds and pretend you're saying what's in your posts to real people in real life. Do you like what you hear?
How much of your social media activity is dedicated to interesting conversation that is unrelated to what you sell?
Jared Fogle, the ex-Subway spokesperson, did some really bad things. I'd rather not talk about what they were. Yesterday he was sentenced to 15 years in prison.
None of that deserves any of my time or attention.
I am, however, interested in whether or not this scandal changed your opinion of Subway.
They of course did the only thing they could do. They severed all ties to him when the scandal broke.
Since then, though, have you eaten at Subway less? Or the same? No one would blame you for continuing to eat there. They hired him before any of it started, and they distanced themselves from him once it did. The question is: did the scandal have any impact on your consumption of Subway products? Consciously or otherwise.
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
Your BRAND is the collection of thoughts, opinions and impressions that the consuming public has of you. It is formed through every interaction they have with you. You must be vigilant in your efforts to keep the promise you make to them, in every area of your business. We will never know the impact Fogle's scandal had on Subway's brand. The point is that your brand is your most important asset. It's precious and must be protected.
Did Subway's brand take a hit? Or are they absolved of responsibility (and therefore protected from any brand damage)?
Car and Driver wrote a very interesting article recently (via Road & Track) about the proliferation of 'crossover' vehicles in the market and specifically, crappy ones. Automakers so quickly responded to consumer demand for an enlarged station wagon that "considerations as varied as styling, performance, efficiency, and handling have been overlooked." In their opinion (and they would know) these products weren't well built, they were quickly built.
This begs the question: is it good or bad for your brand to launch a 'me too' product to capitalize on escalating demand if the product will be made too hastily and as a result, quite poorly?
Toyota is credited with starting this 'sport cute' trend with its popular RAV4 crossover. They are the real geniuses in this discussion because they identified the market need and created the first product to fulfil it. Others scrambled to keep up with the trend at the expense of product quality, which did some level of damage to their brand image. On the flip side, of course, is the brand damage that would have been done if an automaker forewent the timely introduction of a competitive product in the interest of perfecting it first.
Which is better? Launching an inferior, 'me too' product to merely keep up with competitors' offerings? Or, instead, dedicating resources to identifying the next market need and creating a product for that?
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
Think about your industry and your own product lineup. Are you in catch-up mode? Or are you in a market leadership position?
We know what the automakers ended up doing. Would you have done the same thing?
"If you can't explain it simply, you don't understand it well enough."
- Albert Einstein
Truer words about marketing have never been spoken.
The internet age is fast. Consumers want access to products and services more quickly than ever before, but more importantly, they want information about products and services even more quickly, before they decide which products or services to buy.
We use social media to ask our friends for referrals and recommendations, and we get that feedback almost instantaneously. We read product reviews on web sites that are accurate as of that moment. We use apps that allow us to scan product bar codes (in the store!) then tell us where to buy them for the best price. We Google a brand or product then scan the meta descriptions in the results to learn all we need to know, in mere seconds. Our access to information, opinion and evaluation of brands is unprecedentedly fast.
What does this mean for marketers? It means you need to be able to describe what it is that you offer, and why anyone would be interested in buying it, in mere seconds. That means it needs to be simple. Exceedingly simple. If we have but seconds to describe our offer to consumers, it needs to be more concise and appealing than it currently is.
Here are some of the best examples of offers that are exceedingly clear, concise and appealing:
What do all these products and brands have in common? They are all successful. Why? because their offers are so simple and so attractive that everyone is talking about them (especially since the products/brands are easy for anyone to describe). They didn't need massive ad buys to spread the word when they launched these products. They created an offer so simple and so attractive that word spread on its own. Fast. Enabled by the internet.
That precious word-of-mouth advertising is only enabled if the product or brand in question can be explained simply. Just as Einstein foresaw.
What a genius.
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
It's simple (pun intended): Try to describe your offer to someone in 3 seconds or less. And make it good! Anyone can describe an offer in 3 seconds or less. The trick is to describe an offer that's compelling enough to inspire people to talk about it or buy it... in 3 seconds or less. Good luck!
Any simple, attractive products or brands to add to the list?
LESSON FOR MARKETERS:
The FIRST thing to do it the difficult but important work of deciding who your brand wants to reach. It all starts from there. If you've done that already, show it to people that haven't seen it and get their honest opinion about how well you done that.
What do you think of the ad?
Today's consumers get exactly what they want, exactly when they want it.
Loyalty is all but dead because demanding consumers, powered by the internet and enabled by mobile devices, can always find... or should I say are continuously offered... the best offer at the best price. Today Blacks learned that lesson the hard way.
Consumers have immediate, detailed access to the best offers in the market. Consequently, innovators and startups with new products and new ideas are stealing customers and winning business.
What it means for established businesses (especially retailers like Blacks) is that they need to not only keep up with product development and new market offerings, they need to jump ahead and anticipate consumer needs before someone else does. In short, they need to give their consumers a reason to stay. They need to create that thing that no one else has.
To their credit, Blacks invested heavily 13 months ago in a rich rebranding effort that included a revamped logo, website, mobile app and store design. The problem, though, is that none of those things are unique. None of them would create any loyalty, which Blacks so desperately needed. The offer that came closest to something valuable enough to create loyalty was the mobile app, that allowed for prints and other photography-based products (like calendars) to be ordered and delivered. I'm sure you know where this is going...consumers already had apps just like that! What's worse is the length of time it took for the rebranding to fully reach the market. The refreshed store design didn't even happen in most stores before today's announcement.
The stark reality for Blacks is that they failed to create any compelling reason for today's high-maintenance consumers to stay.
So they left.
LESSON FOR MARKETERS:
This is perhaps the simplest, but yet most difficult, challenge for marketers. Create an offer than is unique enough and compelling enough to convince current customers to stay and prospective customers to switch. Much easier said than done, but if you can pull it off, prosperity awaits. Think iPod, RedBull, GoPro, Sharpie and Groupon.
What do you think happened to Blacks?
Target suffered the same fate for basically the same reason. Read about that here.
IHOP has updated its logo, clearly creating a happy face as part of the mark. The smile is also a big part of their new branding effort, which includes a "What are smiles made of?" tagline and a #IHOPSmile social media campaign.
But when I took a closer look at the 'happy face' integrated into the logo....
Am I the only one that sees this??
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
I've never been a big fan of focus groups, mostly because they are extremely difficult to do correctly, and they almost never yield statistically significant data. But in a case like this, getting a bunch of people together that aren't a part of the process (of creating the new logo) might have helped identify this potential likeness. All it takes is for one person to point out what everyone else misses, which can sometimes lead to a different or better outcome.
Did you see it? Does it even matter?
Almost by accident I discovered that one of Derek Jeter's retirement projects (besides dating Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue cover models) is the creation and promotion of a web site about sports written and edited entirely by professional athletes. Here are three things that I really love about this project:
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
There are several blog posts already written and still to come about this, but you need to take away from this post that your job, as a marketer, is to be valuable and unique to your audience. If you can do that well, your audience will do your job for you!
What do you think of the site? What do you think of the site design?
Yes, I'm a marketing nerd, so yes, the Super Bowl ads are worth talking about to me. So here I go!
First, here are the criteria for a great ad:
So, ON TO THE LIST! I tried to select the top 3 ads, but there are 4 clearly superior ads. Hey, at least it creates symmetry, since there are four quarters in a football game! It's a stretch, I know. Here we go:
Q1 - CHEVY
WHY IT'S GREAT: It's certainly memorable, since it terrifies us that the Super Bowl coverage has blacked out!! The message is simple, and it makes us want that truck, which elevates the brand!
Q2 - ESURANCE
WHY IT'S GREAT: This one is exceedingly memorable. The 'sorta you' concept is brilliant, it ties in to pop culture with the Breaking Bad connection, and the script is actually quite funny. I also give it points for the simplicity of the message: coverage specific to YOU. Bonus points for the #sorta hashtag at the end.
Q3 - T-MOBILE
WHY IT'S GREAT: This ad is also extremely memorable. It's funny, and it stars Kim Kardashian West who is one of the biggest celebrities on the planet. I don't have a lot of good things to say about her, but her willingness to poke fun at herself makes the ad more enjoyable. Of all the Super Bowl ads, this one also boasts the clearest message: T-Mobile lets your keep your unused data.
Q4 - ALWAYS
WHY IT'S GREAT: This one excels at all categories. The message is clear and simple ('Hey girls, Always has your back'), it definitely taps into our emotions, and it elevates Always brand in our minds. As added bonuses, the logo is interspersed in the ad, and the #LikeAGirl hashtag is a social media hit.
LESSON FOR MARKETERS
If you're creating an ad (in any form, not just TV), remember the criteria. Can you list them in your head without scrolling back to the top?
Here is a complete compilation of the Super Bowl ads. Which ones do you like better than the four listed here? Drop us a comment!
This blog is written by Glenn Cressman, Share Of Marketing's founder and Chief Share Builder (bio). It covers all things marketing. Feel free to comment!